PDA

View Full Version : Uncle Sam wants US Muslims to serve



Winifred
01-02-2007, 09:21 PM
from the December 27, 2006 edition - http://www.csmonitor.com/2006/1227/p03s01-usmi.html

Uncle Sam wants US Muslims to serve

The Pentagon builds Islamic prayer rooms and hires imams to make military life more appealing.
By Richard Whittle | Contributor to The Christian Science Monitor

WASHINGTON
As US troops battle Islamic extremists abroad, the Pentagon and the armed forces are reaching out to Muslims at home.

An underlying goal is to interest more Muslims in the military, which needs officers and troops who can speak Arabic and other relevant languages and understand the culture of places like Iraq and Afghanistan. The effort is also part of a larger outreach. Pentagon officials say they are striving for mutual understanding with Muslims at home and abroad and to win their support for US war aims. Among the efforts to attract and retain Muslim cadets:

• West Point and the other service academies have opened Muslim prayer rooms, as have military installations.

• Imams serve full- and part-time as chaplains at the academies and some bases.

• Top non-Muslim officers and Pentagon officials have taken to celebrating religious events with Muslims overseas and here in the US.

"There is a message here, and that is that Muslims and the Islamic religion are totally compatible with Western values," says Deputy Defense Secretary Gordon England in an interview.

For the past two years, Mr. England has hosted an iftar, the feast that ends the daytime fast during the Muslim holy month of Ramadan, at the Army Navy Country Club in Arlington, Va. His guests have included ambassadors, leaders of the Muslim-American community, and Muslims who serve in the US armed forces.

President Bush also hosted an iftar at the White House in October, as he has done for several years. Gen. Robert Magnus, the assistant commandant of the Marine Corps, held one the same month at the Marine Corps Barracks in Washington for defense attachés from predominantly Muslim nations.

The US armed services don't recruit by religion, but the Pentagon estimates at least 3,386 Muslims were serving in the US military as of September. No precise figures are available because, while US service members are surveyed on their religion, they aren't required to disclose it. Advocacy groups put the number at 15,000, saying many are reluctant to reveal their religion. African-Americans represent the largest share of Muslims in uniform, they add.

However uncertain the progress, the military is intensifying its outreach.

On June 6 - the anniversary of D-Day, he notes - Mr. England helped dedicate a new Islamic prayer center at the Quantico Marine Corps Base near Washington, whose 6,100 marines include about 24 Muslims, according to Lt. Cmdr. Abuhena Saifulislam, a Navy chaplain who serves as their imam.

The Marines also have allowed Muslims in their ranks at Quantico some dispensations to make it easier to practice their religion, says Lieutenant Commander Saifulislam, a US citizen born and raised in Bangladesh. During Ramadan, "they're allowed to have some time off to prepare for their fasting break and not to go to physical training" while fasting, he says.

Muslim troops say misunderstandings and friction with non-Muslims in uniform arise sometimes, but practicing Islam in a military at war with extremists who profess the same faith isn't a burden, they add.

Petty Officer Third Class Nicholas Burgos, a Sunni Muslim training to be a Navy SEAL, or commando, says instructors sometimes goad him by calling him "Osama bin Burgos" or asking if he's training to help the Taliban. But "it's all in good fun," he insists.

"It's all about how much mental stress you can deal with while you're in training," Petty Officer Burgos says. "I just laugh or have a smirk on my face."

His father, Asadullah Burgos, is the part-time imam at the US Military Academy at West Point, N.Y., whose roughly 4,000 cadets include 32 Muslims, 12 of whom are foreign students.

"There's been some insults and some taunting, but it's been handled at the cadet level," Imam Burgos says. "Usually that's due to ignorance."

Col. John Cook, the senior chaplain at West Point, says that after media reports about the academy's new Muslim prayer room, he got a call from a self-described "concerned citizen" who fretted that "the Muslims are taking over the world."

"I told him, 'I'm a Christian chaplain, but I have the responsibility to provide for other faith groups,' " Colonel Cook says. Protestant, Catholic, and Jewish cadets all have their own chapels at West Point, he notes.

Marine Sgt. Jamil Alkattan, a Sunni Muslim of Syrian heritage from South Bend, Ind., says his religion, his knowledge of Arabic, and his familiarity with Arab culture were major assets during two tours in Iraq.

Not only was he able to teach fellow marines key Arabic phrases and explain that all Muslims aren't extremists, he says, but he also was able to befriend locals, who brought him vital intelligence. "They would come to me and say, 'I know where bombs are,' and this and that," Sergeant Alkattan says. "I never got to sleep. They would come at night time and tell me, 'Hey, I think these guys [insurgents] are trying to set you guys up,' or, 'I've seen these guys with an IED [improvised bomb].' I think it stopped a lot of things that could have happened."

Under a new Middle East Cultural Outreach Program created by the Marine Corps, Sergeant Alkattan is one of six Arab-American marines selected to be stationed in major American cities as liaisons to the Arab-American community and advisers to recruiters.

The program was conceived by Gunnery Sgt. Jamal Baadani, a Muslim born in Cairo who emigrated to Michigan when he was 10.

"It is not a direct recruiting program," says Sergeant Baadani, but its goal is to educate recruiters to avoid cultural no-nos and foster good relations with Arab-American communities. The "overall objective ... is to develop solid relationships with the Arab and Muslim communities for the 21st and 22nd centuries. This isn't something that's just a Band-Aid treatment."

oceanflower
01-02-2007, 10:37 PM
My first reaction to this is to cringe, as I, unfairly I know, associate "Muslim" with "Anti-American." It's how people felt about German-Americans and Japanese-Americans during WWII, wth unfortunate results. But looking at it from a realistic point of view, it must be accepted that in this country the Muslim-American population is growing, and should be integrated into all parts of American society, including the military.

Winifred
01-03-2007, 01:23 AM
Yes, and I think it underlines the importance of true religious freedom to the American way.

Shammy
01-03-2007, 01:34 AM
It's not a bad idea at all. The military targets anyone they can for recruiting including people who aren't yet American citizens. It shouldn't be any different with Muslims, especially when they're U.S. citizens. We need people in the military who know the culture, customs, and language of the people we're fighting against.

oceanflower
01-03-2007, 01:57 AM
Yes, and I think it underlines the importance of true religious freedom to the American way.


It's not a bad idea at all. The military targets anyone they can for recruiting including people who aren't yet American citizens. It shouldn't be any different with Muslims, especially when they're U.S. citizens. We need people in the military who know the culture, customs, and language of the people we're fighting against.

Very good points, Winifred and Shammy.

Rachel
01-03-2007, 04:26 AM
Before I comment I need to say that some of my very closest friends are Muslim
But I am grieved that what is truly spoken by Mohammed in the Koran, is not really understood. Noone and I mean no one that calls themself Muslim can ever, Not EVER, look upon any non Islaamic country as anything but an enemy to be conquered. That is the absolute truth. At some point all Muslims here or in the U.S have to make a decision in a time of war, either do what the Koran, what Allah and his prophet have said are evil and be eternally dammed or fight on the side of Allah alone and help to subdue the entire world.
I fear that our complacency will result in our being subjected to Sharia law at some point and the grief that will come with that is horrendous. I am not talking about individual dear Muslim people, but to the ideology which has never and will never change. We are not talking here about protestant vs Catholic or Mormon or whatever that have their bickerings. We are talking about an ideology that will NEVER for eternity change. Think of Osama who went to school in the states and was used by her to do certain things, and the WHOLE while he was learning how to turn all the knowledge and such as he had aquired to annihilate the U.S. Because to be a true Muslim he had to.
I am so worried about turning a blind eye.No matter what the emams say or what the recruits that are Islaamic say, please I beg of you remember those that took part in 911, all pretended to be nice and friendly and just minding their own business. All for the glory of their ideology.
I am by NO MEANS saying don't love muslims, I happen to and one of them probably more than any other humans outside my family. But the reality is there can never be a meeting of the minds. it is a lie.

This is why I belive this, and it is only a minute part:
Israeli conflict the central doctrines of classical Islam pertaining to the acquisition and use of political power.

CLASSICAL ISLAMIC DOCTRINE ON POLITICAL POWER

4 Islamic teachings on the pursuit of political power, and on all else, rest on two foundation stones, the Koran (God's literal, uncreated word) and the sunnah (the example and teachings of Muhammad).

5 To begin with the sunnah: Muhammad was more than just a prophet. He was also a political leader. He led armies, imposed taxes, signed treaties, ordered punishments, including capital punishment, and acted as judge and lawgiver. The year one in the Muslim calendar is AD 622, the year in which Muhammad established the first Islamic political community in Medina. "From its beginnings, Islam existed and spread as a community-state; it was both a faith and a political order."2 Central to Muhammad's example and teaching is this principle: God is sovereign over all of His creation, and His law must therefore regulate every aspect of human life, including politics. If need be, Muslims must use force to extend governance under God's law around the world. According to traditional sources, at the end of his life Muhammad sent threatening messages to the Persian and Byzantine emperors, and began to prepare his followers for a war to expand Islamic rule beyond Arabia.3

6 The Koran, too, says much about political power and the means by which Muslims should seek it. According to classical Islamic exegesis, the Koran's teachings about the waging of war — a key means to political power — went through three stages.4 First, while still in the pagan city of Mecca (from AD 610 to 622), Muhammad and the earliest Muslims were commanded to use only peaceful means to spread the message of Islam. During this time the Muslims were persecuted severely. In the early Meccan verses of the Koran we read peaceful teachings, for example, "unto you your religion, unto me my religion" (109:1-6). In AD 622 the Muslims migrated to Medina where they founded the first Muslim political community. Around this time the revelations to Muhammad changed: the Muslims were given divine permission to wage war against the Meccans who had driven them from their homes: "Sanction has been given unto those who fight because they have been wronged. . ." (22:39). The Muslims waged a successful war against the Meccans who surrendered and converted to Islam in AD 630. Around this time the divine revelation to Muhammad regarding warfare entered a third phase: God now commanded the Muslims unconditionally to wage war against all non-Muslims until the entire world was governed according to God's law. The Koranic verses containing this command are called the "sword verses," and they include the following: "Make war on them [the unbelievers] until idolatry shall cease and God's religion shall reign supreme" (8:39); "Slay the idolaters wherever you find them" (9:5); "Fight against those to whom the scriptures were given . . . who do not forbid what God and His Apostle have forbidden, and do not embrace the true faith, until they pay tribute out of hand and are utterly subdued" (9:29). These "sword verses" contained in the last parts of the Koran to be revealed ( Suras 8 and 9), are considered by classical exegetes to have repealed or abrogated earlier verses concerning intercourse with non-Muslims, including the more peaceful verses of the Meccan period.

7 The key term in the Islamic law of war is jihad, the verbal noun of the Arabic verb jahada, meaning "to endeavor, to strive, to struggle." Jihad can refer generically to any type of religious struggle, but in about two-thirds of the instances where the verb jahada or its derivatives occur in the Koran, it clearly denotes warfare.5 Moreover, each of the major collections of Muhammad's teachings ( ahadith) includes a book devoted to jihad, and each of these books deals exclusively with warfare.6 Thus, in classical Islamic law the primary meaning of jihad has always been "armed struggle for Islam against infidels and apostates."7

8 According to the traditional understanding, the Muslim community as a whole has a duty to expand the territory and rule of Islam.8 Non-Muslims, e.g. Christians and Jews, are to be invited either to convert to Islam or at least to accept Islamic rule. If they refuse either option, they are to be subjugated by military force. This duty to wage expansionist jihad is a collective duty of all Muslims; that is, if a sufficient number engage in it, the whole community has fulfilled its obligation; if the number of participants is inadequate, the sin rests on all Muslims. The ultimate goal is the imposition of Islamic rule over the entire world. Until that happens the world is divided into two zones: the dar al-Islam or house of Islam and the dar al-Harb or house of war. Between the two is a perpetual state of war, punctuated only by temporary truces, which are not permanent peace treaties but mere tactical pauses for the Muslim side to gather its strength. This was the view of both Sunnis and Shiites until AD 873, after which the Shiites (10-15 percent of Muslims) came to believe that expansionist jihad should be waged only after the return of the last imam at the end of time.9

incka
01-03-2007, 12:25 PM
Well it's good that the US military is willing to take Muslims into it's ranks, especially when to many (including Muslims and Americans) it seems that the war on terror has some element of America-vs-Muslims in it, even though it's not about that at all, it can easily be percieved by people as such.

I think that any measures like this will also decrease threats of terrorism in America, as it will seem a more welcoming society.

But besides all that, I think that the military is in a crisis needing more recruits and will always have the poorest sections of American society fighting for it - and immigrants and ethnic minorities are usually poorer than the Americans whose families migrated there from Europe a few hundred years ago.